______________________________________

________________________________

To Members of the Executive

Notice of a Meeting of the Executive

Wednesday 2 April 2003 at 10.00 am

County Hall, Oxford


Chris Impey
Assistant Chief Executive

Contact officer :Deborah Mitchell (Tel: 01865 815463 ; E-mail)

Membership

Councillors

 

 

Keith R Mitchell

-

Leader of the Council

Margaret Godden

-

Deputy Leader of the Council

Tony Crabbe

-

Executive Member for Schools

Neil Fawcett

-

Executive Member for Learning & Culture

David Robertson

-

Executive Member for Transport

Anne Purse

-

Executive Member for Strategic Planning & Waste Management

Janet Godden

-

Executive Member for Children & Young People

Don Seale

-

Executive Member for Community Care & Health

John Farrow

-

Executive Member for Community Safety

The Agenda follows. Decisions taken at the meeting will become effective at the end of the working day on 10 April 2003 unless called in by that date for review by the appropriate Scrutiny Committee.

Copies of this Notice, Agenda and supporting papers are circulated to all Members of the County Council.

AGENDA

Addenda

  1. Apologies for Absence
  2. Declarations of Interest
  3. Minutes
  4. To confirm the minutes of the meeting held on 18 March 2003 (EX3) and to receive for information any matters arising therefrom.

  5. Petitions and Public Address

    see Addenda
  6. Regional Transport Strategy
  7. Executive Member: Transport
    Forward Plan Ref: 2003/42
    Contact Officer: Andy Barton/Peter Mann (01865 815479)

    Report by Assistant Director of Environmental Services (Transport Development) (EX5).

    In June 2002 the South East England Regional Assembly (SEERA) published a draft revised Regional Transport Strategy (RTS) ‘From Crisis to Cutting Edge’ for consultation. In a report to the Executive on the 4 September 2002 comments were made which were fed back to SEERA on the Strategy. The RTS has now progressed to the next level of the adoption process, and in January 2003 the Secretary of State began his formal consultation process. This report provides some background to the Strategy and provides comments by the Assistant Director (Transport Development), recommending that these form the basis of the County Council’s response to this final consultation stage.

    The current version of the RTS is clearer and easier to read and comprehend as the policies and the supporting statements have been separated into two documents. Many of the areas which caused confusion and concern in the earlier version, have been clarified. Virtually all the policies and approaches highlighted within the document are in line with current policies and proposals in the Structure Plan and Transport Plan. These include support for the promotion of East West Rail and the relocation of Oxford Station. It is particularly pleasing to see that the Oxford Transport Strategy has been singled out as a case study of Best Practice. However, a number of issues remain of particular concern. These include the treatment of congestion charging and the supply and management of on and off street parking.

    The Executive is RECOMMENDED to:

          1. agree that the report and Annex C form the basis of a written response to the Secretary of State on the draft Regional Transport Strategy; and
          2. note the updated position on Multi Modal Studies.

  8. Market Square/Wessex Way, Bicester - Traffic Measures to follow the Skimmingdish Lane Improvement
  9. Executive Member: Transport
    Forward Plan Ref: 2003/18
    Contact Officer: David Clough (01865 815743)

    Report by Assistant Director of Environmental Services (Transport Development) (EX6).

    This report presents the results of the appraisal of alternative traffic routes that could support the plan for the pedestrianisation of the Market Square based on Option 5 that was previously considered by the Executive on 29 October 2002. The main purpose of this report is to explain why any alternative routes to Wessex Way have been found unacceptable. The report outlines the results of the study, and considers the predicted levels of diverted traffic, the number of properties that would be affected by changes in traffic flow, the effect on junctions and traffic management changes that would need to be made to junctions or the highway network. It concludes that it is not desirable to implement the proposed Option 5 scheme without building the extension of Wessex Way

    The Executive is RECOMMENDED to:

          1. agree that the approved Option for Market Square (Option 5) is not achievable without the extension of Wessex Way; and
          2. instruct officers to examine further in consultation with Cherwell District Council and Bicester Town Council the environmental and road safety implications of the extension of Wessex Way and the pedestrianisation of Market Square.

  10. Bus Stop Standards and Procurement of Bus Shelters
  11. Executive Member: Transport
    Forward Plan Ref: 2002/236
    Contact Officer: David Taylor (01865 816519)

    Report by Assistant Director of Environmental Services (Transport Development) (EX7).

    Consultants Halcrow were commissioned last year to investigate how this Council could facilitate higher standards for Bus Stop Infrastructure and Shelters. A draft design guide for stop and shelter layouts has now been produced after considerable discussion with stakeholders. Consultation is underway on the revised draft, with a view to printing and issuing it to relevant parties this summer. A copy of the draft guide has been placed in the Members’ Resource Centre.

    The larger Town and Parish Councils and the Oxfordshire Association of Local Councils were invited to a seminar on 3 March 2003, where the County Council’s aspirations for higher infrastructure standards were expressed in the context of the Premium Routes strategy and the Council’s targets for growth in bus usage. There was general agreement that the County Council should investigate the possibility of negotiating a county-wide contract for the provision and maintenance of advertising and non-advertising shelters, for those local Councils wishing to opt in.

    The Executive is RECOMMENDED to:

          1. note the progress towards the production of a Bus Stop Infrastructure design guide;
          2. authorise officers to pursue a negotiated contract procedure for the procurement of new bus shelters for the Premium Routes Network and elsewhere in Oxfordshire; and
          3. ask officers to report back to a future meeting on the full financial implications of entering into such a contract.

  12. Children’s Disability Services - Respite Care Partnership Arrangements

Executive Member: Children & Young People
Forward Plan Ref: 2003/72
Contact Officer: Phil Hodgson, Head of Social Care for Children (01865 815833)

Report by Director for Social & Health Care (EX8).

In December 2002 the Executive agreed to proceed with proposals to develop an integrated residential respite scheme through a partnership between the County Council, Barnardo’s and the Oxfordshire Learning Disability NHS Trust. The redesigned service would include the children’s residential respite provision and an expanded community play and leisure service.

This report outlines progress on the project, which has been managed by a steering group of senior managers from the three partnership agencies with input from interested parents. Consultation and information-sharing with parents and children will continue throughout the project. Architects have completed an initial feasibility study of a range of sites, as a result of which three sites have been selected: Sycamore in Banbury, bungalows in Saxon Way in Oxford and Summerfield in Abingdon. These sites have been chosen because the existing buildings can be most easily and economically converted within the shortest timescales to make them fit the purpose. The report gives estimated financial and staffing implications based on this option, and describes how associated leisure and play services are being developed as part of the overall partnership project.

The Executive is RECOMMENDED to:-

          1. note the progress towards the development of a new respite care service and associated play and leisure services, through the partnership between the County Council, the Oxfordshire Learning Disability NHS Trust and Barnardo’s;
          2. endorse the plans to develop the three centres at Sycamore, Oxford, Saxon Way and Summerfield, on the basis outlined in the report, including the estimated finance and staffing implications and project management arrangements;
          3. agree the establishment of an informal Respite Care Development Reference Group, made up of representatives from the three partner agencies, to oversee the service redesign and implementation, on the basis that the County Council representation should be the Executive Members for Children & Young People and Community Care & Health together with the Director for Social & Health Care or their respective nominees.

  1. Children's Panel

Executive Member: Children & Young People
Forward Plan Ref: 2003/71
Contact Officer: Phil Hodgson, Head of Social Care for Children (01865 815833)

The Director for Social & Health Care reports as follows:

The Executive on 1 October 2002 agreed that a Corporate Parenting Panel should be established, to monitor the Council’s performance in relation to children looked after. The report published in January 2003 of Lord Laming’s Inquiry into the death of Victoria Climbié recommended that councillors should receive information about policy and practice issues in relation to children in need. To meet this recommendation it is proposed that the Corporate Parenting Panel’s remit should be extended to include this function, and be established as a Children’s Panel with the following terms of reference:

    1. To discuss national and local policy issues which affect children in need and children looked after and undertake strategy development.
    2. To receive quarterly reports on specified performance indicators relating to the management of children in need and children looked after.
    3. To undertake general performance management of services for children in need and children looked after and alert the relevant Scrutiny Committee to matters of concern.

The Executive in October 2002 agreed that the Corporate Parenting Panel should consist of nine members, three from each political group, but to include the 3 members who serve on the Council’s Adoption & Fostering Panels – currently Councillors Janet Godden, Ted Cooper and Mrs Anda Fitzgerald O’Connor. The two other members from each group (nominations for which were subsequently received), were expected to have a particular interest "in education and in community safety". However, it is felt more appropriate for the Children’s Panel that those other six members should comprise the Executive Member for Schools together with members who have a specific interest in the areas of Learning & Culture and Social & Health Care.

It is envisaged that the Panel would meet quarterly and be chaired by the Executive Member for Children & Young People.

The Executive is RECOMMENDED to agree the setting up of a Children’s Panel on the terms set out above, and that the political groups be requested to review their nominations to the Panel accordingly.

  1. Fair Access to Care Services

Executive Member: Community Care & Health
Forward Plan Ref: 2003/31
Contact Officer: Lorna Brown, Head of Social Care for Adults (01865 815828)

Report by Director for Social & Health Care (EX10).

The Department of Health’s Fair Access to Care Services Guidance sets the eligibility framework for adult social care for councils to use when setting and applying their eligibility criteria. The eligibility criteria describe the eligible needs the council will meet. Councils have responsibility to determine the level of resources allocated to social care for adults. The right to set eligibility criteria in line with the resources allocated is retained. There is no intention that individuals with similar needs in different parts of the country should necessarily receive the same level of service.

A new requirement under the guidance is a face to face review of those receiving services, at a minimum interval of a year, by an ’appropriate council professional’. Reviews undertaken solely by providers of service are no longer acceptable. A review becomes the higher level activity and incorporates any reassessment of need against the eligibility criteria: this is a change of emphasis.

The Executive is RECOMMENDED to:

          1. approve the revised eligibility criteria for all adults as described in the report, for immediate implementation;
          2. note the changes in practice, both in language and process, embodied in the guidance;
          3. request the Director for Social & Health Care to report on the first six months of implementation to the Executive Members for Community Care & Health and Children & Young People.

  1. Fire Service Dispute
  2. Executive Member: Community Safety
    Forward Plan Ref: 2003/51
    Contact Officer: John Parry, Chief Fire Officer (01865855205)

    The Chief Fire Officer will give an oral update on the Fire Service dispute in the light of national negotiations.

    Subject to any further information that may be reported at the meeting, the Executive is RECOMMENDED to note the position.

  3. Treasury Management Strategy for 2003/04

Executive Member: Leader of the Council
Forward Plan Ref: 2003/41
Contact Officer: Donna Ross, Financial Manager, Treasury Services (01865 815422)

Report by Director for Resources (EX12).

This report sets out a Treasury Management Strategy for 2003/04 and covers both the Council’s Debt Management and the daily Cashflow. The Strategy may be summarised as follows:

    1. take up the maximum Public Works Loan Board (PWLB) quota of £45.4 million to finance the capital programme;
    2. continue to monitor interest rates to ensure that we borrow from the PWLB at the most advantageous rate;
    3. continue to monitor the performance of Alliance Capital;
    4. expand our short-term investment options by using new low risk areas available to local authorities, namely Money Market Funds and Debt Management Account;
    5. implement the revised CIPFA Code of Practice on Treasury Management in the Public Services.
    6. The Executive is RECOMMENDED to:

          1. adopt the key recommendations of CIPFA’s Code of Practice for Treasury Management in the Public Services, as set out in Annex 1 to the report;
          2. adopt the Treasury Management Policy Statement attached at Annex 2;
          3. subject to (d) below, endorse the proposals set out in the report:
          4. (i) to keep the range for fixed interest debt at 75 to 100%;

            (ii) to add a Money Market Fund to the approved list of investments with a limit of up to £15 million and to delegate the selection of a Fund to the Head of Finance; and

            (iii) to add the Debt Management Account to the approved list of investments with a limit of up to £15 million;

          5. refer the report to the Corporate Governance Scrutiny Committee for comments, particularly in respect of the proposed strategy for the control of the Council’s borrowing, with a view to making a recommendation on the strategy to the June 2003 Council.

  1. Communications Mast, Burford School
  2. Executive Member: Leader of the Council, Schools
    Forward Plan Ref: 2003/73
    Contact Officer: John Wilby, Assistant Property Officer (01865 815589)

    Report by Assistant Director of Environmental Services (Property) (EX13).

    The Council agreed in 2000 a policy that radio masts should not be sited on Council property within 200 metres of school land except for Fire Service property. O2 Airwaves have erected without County Council consent a mast on property in a position which conflicts with that policy. It is recommended that in the circumstances the Executive agree to a waiver of the policy to permit the mast to be retained: emission levels from the mast, including the beam of greatest intensity, will be many times below the levels that have now been adopted as a national standard. 02 Airwave have also offered to carry out monitoring on the school site to confirm the emission levels

    The Burford School and School Governors have been asked to comment on the mast and their views will be reported to the meeting.

    If the mast is retained in its existing position then a revised freehold access must be provided to the County Council’s land. 02 Airwave has agreed to negotiate this with the adjoining landowner at 02 Airwave’s expense including the Council’s total costs.

    The Executive is RECOMMENDED to approve a waiver of the County Council’s existing policy on the siting of masts in order to allow the mast to remain at Tanners Lane Burford subject to:-

          1. the negotiation of acceptable terms for a lease;
          2. the provision of an alternative freehold access, as described in the report.

  3. Representation on Strategic Outside Bodies 2003/04
  4. Executive Member: Leader of the Council
    Forward Plan Ref: 2003/4
    Contact Officer: John Leverton, Head of Committee Services (01865 815314)

    The Assistant Chief Executive reports as follows:

    The Executive is responsible for appointments to "strategic" outside bodies (ie those noted on the list complied by the Executive and endorsed by full Council). The current list of bodies and appointees is appended (EX14). As shown in the list (Part A), many of the appointments are expressed to be for the duration of the Council Year. New appointments (or re-appointments) for those bodies now need to be made for 2003/04. No action is required in relation to the bodies in Part B of the list.

    The Executive is RECOMMENDED to make appointments to the bodies listed in Part A of EX14 for the 2003/04 Council Year.

  5. Forward Plan and Future Business

    see Addenda

Executive Member: All
Contact Officer: John Leverton (01865 815314)

The publication date of the next Forward Plan, for the period May 2003 – August 2003, is 17th April 2003. It will therefore be necessary to determine its content at this meeting. Recommendations for additions and amendments are attached as EX15 - Schedules 1-3.(download as .doc file)

Items from the Forward Plan (as now proposed to be updated) for the next two meetings appear in Schedule 4.

The Executive is RECOMMENDED to:

(a) agree the additions and amendments set out in Schedules 1 - 3 for the purpose of the Forward Plan for the ensuing four months;

(b) subject to (a) above, note the items currently identified for forthcoming meetings as set out in Schedule 4.

March 2003

ADDENDA

Item

4. Petitions and Public Address

Petition

 

Subject

Presented by

Split site problems, St Philip and St James School, Oxford

Ms Ruth Shalev

Speaker(s)

 

Item

Speaker

6. Market Square/Wessex Way, Bicester

Councillor Leslie Sibley

Councillor Charles Shouler

8. Respite Care Partnership Arrangements

Mr Ivor Sunman, FORCe

Councillor Barbara Gatehouse

15. Forward Plan and Future Business

The Executive is asked to note the following amendments to the Schedules at EX15:

Schedule 1

Amend the date of the Private Finance Initiative - Schools item to 13 May 2003 and delete from Schedule 4 accordingly

Add:

  • Chewing Gum on Pavements

To consider action in conjunction with other authorities countywide (referred by Council on a motion by Cllr Patrick Greene)

Transport

13 May 2003

  • Vehicular Traffic on the Ridgeway

To consider promoting traffic orders banning non-essential vehicles on specific sections if shown to be appropriate (referred by Council on a motion by Cllr Brian Hodgson)

Learning & Culture

13 May 2003

  • Concessionary Fares

To consider joining the district councils in giving the new entitlement the widest publicity possible (referred by Council on a motion by Cllr Roy Mold)

Transport

13 May 2003

  • Planning for Housing Development

To consider advising the Council on a motion by Cllr Ken Harper on the location of housing development and the provision of affordable housing and homes for key workers.

Strategic Planning & Waste Management

13 May 2003

  • Discretionary Awards for Students

Determination of the County Council’s Policy for 2002/03

Schools

13 May 2003

  • Orchard Fields Primary School, Banbury

Outline project appraisal for redevelopment scheme

Schools

13 May 2003

  • Biodiversity in Oxfordshire

To consider a request by the Environment Scrutiny Committee for an assurance that biodiversity is properly taken into account in the relevant policies and plans which the Executive determines

Strategic Planning & Waste Management

24 June 2003

Schedule 2

Additional Retiming: 2003/25 (to September)

Return to TOP